autox
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Fort Myers - Speed in Turns - rules writing is hard

To: "Gregg Lee" <gregglee@htcomp.net>
Subject: Re: Fort Myers - Speed in Turns - rules writing is hard
From: "Paul Leonard" <pleonard@miraclemethod.com>
Date: Tue, 21 Feb 2006 12:55:19 -0700
One could also argue that you are ALWAYS turning during an autocross ... 
therefore this guideline contradicts the mid to low 60's guideline.

Gregg Lee wrote:

>I have long regarded the 45mph turn speed rule as the vaguest of guidelines.
>"Turns should not normally allow speeds in excess of 45 mph," seems
>superficially clear, but it depends on critical definitions.
>
>What is a turn?  How many degrees?  Below a certain radius?  Is a slalom a
>series of turns?  Is a slightly arcing straight a turn?  Where in the turn
>is speed measured?  At the apex?  Is trail braking into the turn part of the
>turn of part of the straight?
>
>So someone is going to say if it quacks like a turn it is a turn.  Fair
>enough, but quacking is a judgment call.  So combined with "not normally"
>this confirms that this is a guideline and not a rule one may apply with
>precision.
>
>Think about this before trying to write a "never" rule while avoiding
>unintended consequences.  The common sense rules (1.3) for course design
>should work.  The question is why it apparently didn't in this case.   
>
>
>Gregg Lee  




<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>