triumphs
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: [TR] Threads and Bolts

To: Dave <dave1massey@cs.com>, levilevi@comcast.net, triumphs@autox.team.net
Subject: Re: [TR] Threads and Bolts
From: Michael Porter <mdporter@dfn.com>
Date: Thu, 24 Nov 2016 17:13:23 -0700
Delivered-to: mharc@autox.team.net
Delivered-to: triumphs@autox.team.net
References: <4867D657-8691-4AA6-9F95-D531E68A26A4@comcast.net> <15897ad553d-45b2-6ff5@webprd-m19.mail.aol.com>
User-agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.1; WOW64; rv:45.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/45.5.0
This is a multi-part message in MIME format.
--===============6210737388249248326==
 boundary="------------79DF158DD1DD44F73DECAC8F"

This is a multi-part message in MIME format.
--------------79DF158DD1DD44F73DECAC8F
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit

On 11/24/2016 11:51 AM, Dave wrote:
> Bolts with no slashes are grade two.  The grade of the bolt is 
> indicated by the number of slashes plus two.  I do not recommend grade 
> two for suspension duty.
>
> I've heard said that the trade-off with Grade 8 bolts is that they are 
> stronger but more brittle.  Since I am not a mechanical engineer I 
> cannot make a recommendation on substituting a grade 8 for a grade 5 
> but I would be concerned that the increased brittle nature may be a 
> detriment. Considering the seriousness of the consequences of a 
> suspension failure I would think again about making substitutions.  
> And just about anything you need is available next business day from 
> McMaster Carr (and other sources, certainly).  But you may have to buy 
> more than you need and pay shipping.
>
> I don't think fine thread vs coarse thread makes much difference.

Brittleness is relative.  The optimum condition for a strong bolt is 
toughness, the combination of tensile strength with resistance to both 
deformation and crack propagation.  It's just a function of metal 
crystalline behavior that higher tensile strengths are inversely 
proportional to rate of deformation.  The general perception is that 
bolts with very high tensile strength offer no protection from sudden 
breakage once the yield point is reached, but that's not exactly true.  
A lot depends upon the loads imposed.  If a grade 5 bolt works reliably 
in an application, breakage is very unlikely with a grade 8, because the 
grade 8 yield point is higher. This also allows for somewhat more 
clamping force, thus reducing the tendency of the fastened parts to move 
around under load.

The latter is important, because any bolt loaded in shear will fail at 
about 65% of UTS (ultimate tensile strength).  Even so, I've seen grade 
8 bolts that have deformed badly without shearing.  For example, on the 
buses we built, the rear axle was attached to a pair of spring beams 
(the item carrying the air springs that supported the weight of the bus 
and transmitted those loads to the axle). Each one was attached with 
four 3/4" grade 8 bolts in a box pattern, with a precision center pin to 
positively locate the axle.  Due to an engineering error (through holes 
too large), under big side loads (like the driver whacking a curb while 
in motion--much more common than one would think, especially in NYC), 
the spring beam would laterally rotate around the center pin, putting 
the bolts in direct shear.  Those dynamic loads, due to excessive 
movement, were much larger than the clamping load because movement adds 
kinetic energy. I saw one of those grade 8 bolts after such 
mistreatment, and it had an "S" curve in it, so that the centerline at 
the head of the bolt was offset from the centerline at the bottom of the 
bolt by nearly 1/2", and yet, the bolt had not cracked or broken.  
That's where the toughness of the bolt comes in--which depends upon a 
number of factors, such as the alloy, the kind of heat treatment, 
precipitation hardening, tempering and anti-corrosion coatings (to 
prevent corrosion cracking).

To my mind, a properly-made grade 8 bolt will be superior in performance 
to any grade 5 bolt, especially in suspension work. It's important to 
know the loads imposed, though.  In racing, a grade 5 will be fine in 
areas where the maximum load imposed will be sufficiently below the UTS 
of the bolt, and the clamped pieces are inspected regularly for 
stretched or deformed bolts, but the extra insurance of higher yield 
strength and higher clamping force make a grade 8 preferable.  I'd much 
rather have a bolt that never reaches its yield point under maximum load 
than one that yields and deforms before failure.


Cheers.

-- 


Michael Porter
Roswell, NM


Never let anyone drive you crazy when you know it's within walking distance....


--------------79DF158DD1DD44F73DECAC8F
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit

<html>
  <head>
    <meta content="text/html; charset=windows-1252"
      http-equiv="Content-Type">
  </head>
  <body bgcolor="#FFFFFF" text="#000000">
    <div class="moz-cite-prefix">On 11/24/2016 11:51 AM, Dave wrote:<br>
    </div>
    <blockquote cite="mid:15897ad553d-45b2-6ff5@webprd-m19.mail.aol.com"
      type="cite"><font face="Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif"
        color="black" size="4"><font size="4">Bolts with no slashes are
          grade two.  The grade of the bolt is indicated by the number
          of slashes plus two.  I do not recommend grade two for
          suspension duty.  <br>
          <br>
          I've heard said that the trade-off with Grade 8 bolts is that
          they are stronger but more brittle.  Since I am not a
          mechanical engineer I cannot make a recommendation on
          substituting a grade 8 for a grade 5 but I would be concerned
          that the increased brittle nature may be a detriment.
          Considering the seriousness of the consequences of a
          suspension failure I would think again about making
          substitutions.  And just about anything you need is available
          next business day from McMaster Carr (and other sources,
          certainly).  But you may have to buy more than you need and
          pay shipping.</font><br>
        <br>
        <font size="4">I don't think fine thread vs coarse thread makes
          much difference.<br>
        </font></font></blockquote>
    <br>
    Brittleness is relative.  The optimum condition for a strong bolt is
    toughness, the combination of tensile strength with resistance to
    both deformation and crack propagation.  It's just a function of
    metal crystalline behavior that higher tensile strengths are
    inversely proportional to rate of deformation.  The general
    perception is that bolts with very high tensile strength offer no
    protection from sudden breakage once the yield point is reached, but
    that's not exactly true.  A lot depends upon the loads imposed.  If
    a grade 5 bolt works reliably in an application, breakage is very
    unlikely with a grade 8, because the grade 8 yield point is higher. 
    This also allows for somewhat more clamping force, thus reducing the
    tendency of the fastened parts to move around under load.  <br>
    <br>
    The latter is important, because any bolt loaded in shear will fail
    at about 65% of UTS (ultimate tensile strength).  Even so, I've seen
    grade 8 bolts that have deformed badly without shearing.  For
    example, on the buses we built, the rear axle was attached to a pair
    of spring beams (the item carrying the air springs that supported
    the weight of the bus and transmitted those loads to the axle). 
    Each one was attached with four 3/4" grade 8 bolts in a box pattern,
    with a precision center pin to positively locate the axle.  Due to
    an engineering error (through holes too large), under big side loads
    (like the driver whacking a curb while in motion--much more common
    than one would think, especially in NYC), the spring beam would
    laterally rotate around the center pin, putting the bolts in direct
    shear.  Those dynamic loads, due to excessive movement, were much
    larger than the clamping load because movement adds kinetic energy. 
    I saw one of those grade 8 bolts after such mistreatment, and it had
    an "S" curve in it, so that the centerline at the head of the bolt
    was offset from the centerline at the bottom of the bolt by nearly
    1/2", and yet, the bolt had not cracked or broken.  That's where the
    toughness of the bolt comes in--which depends upon a number of
    factors, such as the alloy, the kind of heat treatment,
    precipitation hardening, tempering and anti-corrosion coatings (to
    prevent corrosion cracking).<br>
    <br>
    To my mind, a properly-made grade 8 bolt will be superior in
    performance to any grade 5 bolt, especially in suspension work. 
    It's important to know the loads imposed, though.  In racing, a
    grade 5 will be fine in areas where the maximum load imposed will be
    sufficiently below the UTS of the bolt, and the clamped pieces are
    inspected regularly for stretched or deformed bolts, but the extra
    insurance of higher yield strength and higher clamping force make a
    grade 8 preferable.  I'd much rather have a bolt that never reaches
    its yield point under maximum load than one that yields and deforms
    before failure.<br>
    <br>
    <br>
    Cheers.<br>
    <font size="4"><font face="Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif"></font></font><br>
    <pre class="moz-signature" cols="72">-- 


Michael Porter
Roswell, NM


Never let anyone drive you crazy when you know it's within walking 
distance....</pre>
  </body>
</html>

--------------79DF158DD1DD44F73DECAC8F--


--===============6210737388249248326==
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
Content-Disposition: inline


** triumphs@autox.team.net **

Archive: http://www.team.net/archive

--===============6210737388249248326==--

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>