[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Front Shroud - Original versus Reproduction

To: "Diann Jones" <diann.lindsay@xtra.co.nz>, <healeys@Autox.Team.Net>
Subject: Re: Front Shroud - Original versus Reproduction
From: "Rich C" <richchrysler@quickclic.net>
Date: Tue, 9 Nov 2004 21:53:25 -0500
The metal man I use(old fashined English panel beater) had some experience 
with a repro front shroud last year. He is used to making and repairing 
originals even if extensively damaged or (more often) rotted. This 
particular time his customer had imported a new front shroud for a BJ8, then 
called in the metal man to try to make everything work. It was quite a 
They eventually ended up repairing the original for much less than reworking 
the repro. The repro went out for sale. I don't know where it ended up.
I certainly wouldn't be trusting a repro shroud to position bulkheads, etc.
Meanwhile much the same can be said for the repro fenders I've seen. They 
don't have the fullness (depth of pressing) of the originals. So far we've 
always been better off using original pieces even if they require extensive 
One more thing to add re front shrouds. Visually the early 6 cylinder 
roadster shroud looks the same as a Mk2 roadster but the grille opening is 
in fact different. The vertical bar style grille opening is about 1/2" 
taller opening. The mounting pin holes at each side on the earlier shroud go 
out to the right and left while the later opening has the pin going straight 
The later grille will not quite fit correctly into the earlier grille 
opening without a lot of cheating and reworking of the surrounding lip.
Of course with the wind up window cars (BJ7 and BJ8) the only difference is 
in the side lamp configurations (small, large, 2 vs. 4).
Rich Chrysler
----- Original Message ----- 
From: "Diann Jones" <diann.lindsay@xtra.co.nz>
To: <healeys@autox.team.net>
Sent: Tuesday, November 09, 2004 5:07 PM
Subject: Front Shroud - Original versus Reproduction

> I'm on the hunt for comments from others, who have knowledge or who've had
> experience with the fitting of a new reproduction front shroud.  This is 
> one
> that would have been bought, complete as one piece.
> Would they be good enough to use as a template to ensure the front 
> bulkhead is
> being positioned correctly onto the chassis?
> Also what's their fit like with the fenders and hood?
> Plus, how good are they when comparing the shaping (visual lines) to an
> original shroud?
> How interchangeable are the original front shrouds from Healey to Healey? 
> Is
> this another area of slight variances between cars, or is the fitment 
> quite
> uniform?
> Are we best to go new or try and track down a very good original (late 
> BJ8)
> shroud that hasn't been involved in an accident.  Which ever way - we'd 
> have
> to ship out to New Zealand - one needs to ponder their choices carefully.
> Has anyone had experience with the reproduction front fenders?  -  good or
> bad!
> All comments greatly appreciated.
> Cheers
> Diann

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>