[Shotimes] OT: allstate vs liberty mutual vs 21st century

[Bill Murray]

I have had a few claims through Statefarm and I have always been satisfied with the resolution.  They have always been willing to work with me to come to a fair monetary value when they totaled the car, taking recent work done to the car into consideration.  I don't think this will help Ian though as I don't think they are writing new policies in NJ for auto, unless you have homeowners insurance through them as well.

Bill Murray
-----Original Message-----
From: "Al Fitz" <alfitz@alfitz.com>
Date: 01/21/05 11:29 AM
To: "Shylo McKinsey" <mrfluffy02@yahoo.com>
Cc: "_ShoTimes" <Shotimes@autox.team.net>
Subject: Re: [Shotimes] OT: allstate vs liberty mutual vs 21st century

My experience is that Allstate is one of the WORST insurance companies around.
It's not just my thinking, they consistently score near the bottom of the list
for poor customer satisfaction. State Farm is close to the top companies for
customer satisfaction.

Al Fitz
alfitz@alfitz.com
SHO Parts at
http://www.alfitz.com/sho
*************************************************************************
PLEASE INCLUDE A COPY OF THIS EMAIL IN YOUR REPLY
*************************************************************************

  ----- Original Message -----
  From: Shylo McKinsey
  To: Ian Fisher
  Cc: TaurusSHO
  Sent: Thursday, January 20, 2005 11:30 PM
  Subject: Re: [Shotimes] OT: allstate vs liberty mutual vs 21st century


  Whatever you do, stay away from Farmers. I'm
  (well...my insurance company is) in the fight of my
  life trying to get my car fixed. I got backed into
  yesterday. Can send people some pics if they want to
  see the carnage. Worst part is, I was just sitting in
  the car parked when it happened. Poor car... :-(

  Shylo McKinsey

  '91 White MTX

  --- Ian Fisher <dataflash@yahoo.com> wrote:

  > Anyone have any experience with these companies? My
  > family is currently insured with allstate but my
  > sister is thinking of leaving Allstate for liberty
  > mutual or 21st century as they are much cheaper. I
  > may
  > do the same if I can get a similar deal. I've never
  > had to file a claim with allstate so I don't know
  > what
  > they are really like.
  >
  > I pay ~$1200 full coverage on the SHO (1993) a year
  > with allstate. I am 25, unmarried. That's for NJ
  >
  > Sister is 29, unmarried, lives in IL and drives a 96
  > Subaru Imprezza. I think she is paying close to 1G
  > for