land-speed
[Top] [All Lists]

RE: Welding vs Brazing

To: "'Russel Mack'" <rtmack@concentric.net>, ardunbill@webtv.net,
Subject: RE: Welding vs Brazing
From: "Albaugh, Neil" <albaugh_neil@ti.com>
Date: Wed, 8 Jan 2003 10:05:44 -0600
Russ;

Bike frames are built two different ways-- with lugs and without lugs. There
are custom frame fabricators who swear that one or the other is the best--
there is no agreement about which is "best" way to join tubing.

A lugged joint is made by slipping a square-cut end of tubing into a lug
fitting and then nickel-silver brazing the joint with a thin-flowing alloy
such as the Allstate #11 that Howard mentioned. Capillary action wicks the
brazing rod up into the joint and it forms a good, strong shear joint. 

A non-lugged joint is fabricated by fillet brazing with Allstate #13 (or
similar). The weld bead looks just like a conventional weld except for its
silvery-gold color. In this type of joint, two tubes are joined directly; no
intermediate "TinkerToy" lug is used.

Which joint is stronger? I've never seen any reliable test data, only strong
opinions and, again, there is no agreement. Fabricators do agree that making
a lugged joint is far easier and cheaper (labor) because the only end
preparation it needs is to be hacksaw cut whereas a non-lugged joint
requires a really tight fit and that ain't easy!

Regards, Neil     Tucson, AZ

///  unsubscribe/change address requests to majordomo@autox.team.net  or try
///  http://www.team.net/mailman/listinfo
///  Archives at http://www.team.net/archive/land-speed
///  what is needed.  It isn't that difficult, folks.


<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>